Collin County Community College District Responds to Whistleblower Lawsuit

Collin County Community College District has responded to the whistleblower suit referred to here and here.

The district makes three filings: Defendant’s Answer, Defendant’s Motion to Transfer Venue, and Defendant’s Plea to the Jurisdiction.

The answer begins with a general denial.  That is a formalistic pleading that means the defendant resists the plaintiffs’ claims, but it tells you nothing about the defendant’s actual contentions.  The answer does, however, go on the assert affirmative defenses, which tell us a little more.  The asserted affirmative defenses are that defendant would have treated the plaintiffs the same even if they had not blown a whistle, that defendant is immune from plaintiffs’ claims, that the court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction, that the claims are barred by limitations, and that plaintiffs have failed to mitigate their damages.  I am in no position to comment on the merits of those defenses, but they are generally the sort of defenses you would expect to see in a case of this nature.

The motion to transfer venue asks that the case be transferred from Dallas County to Collin County.  Plaintiffs claim only that venue in Dallas County is permissible, not that it is mandatory.  Defendant does not allege that plaintiffs are wrong in filing in Dallas County.  They argue instead that venue in Collin County would be more convenient for all concerned.  This is an appeal to the discretion of the judge.  I have no idea what the judge will do.  For those not familiar with the relevant geography, Dallas and Collin counties adjoin, and both are part of what is sometimes referred to as the Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex.

The plea to the jurisdiction is the most interesting.  It is based on the concept that all levels of government are immune from lawsuits unless the legislature has specifically waived that immunity.  This immunity dates back to ancient England, where the king could not be sued in his own courts.

The legislature has waived immunity to whistleblower suits, but defendant asserts that a plaintiff’s failure to meet any necessary element of a whistleblower suit is a jurisdictional defect.  If the court determines there is a jurisdictional defect, the court must dismiss the suit without trial.  I do not know the facts of the case well enough to say whether there actually is a jurisdictional defect.  I do know, however, that governmental bodies file these pleadings in every case.  Just because it is filed does not mean that it is meritorious.

Now both parties have made their initial moves in the case, and the litigation can commence in earnest.

Plaintiffs included a routine request for disclosure with their petition, so presumably some time toward the end of October defendant will produce relevant potential evidence.

Related Posts:

Notice of Past-Due Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

Delinquent Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

Due Date for Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

Motion for New Trial

Request for Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

Plea to Jurisdiction Granted

Venue Tranferred to Collin County

Plaintiff’s Response to Motion to Transfer Venue

Hearing Date

College District’s Response to Lawsuit

College District President Resigns

Report of Corruption in Collin County Community College District

Advertisements

30 thoughts on “Collin County Community College District Responds to Whistleblower Lawsuit

  1. Just randomly stumbled upon your blog, but this is super interesting. I just started law school/don’t know too much, but it definitely relates to my Civil Procedure class which seems like such a settled and antiquated subject. Obviously, jurisdictional issues/arguments still exist. Kind of cool!

  2. Pingback: Hearing Date for Collin County Community College District’s Motion to Transfer Venue and Plea to the Jurisdiction | Kenneth Bennight

  3. Pingback: Collin County Community College District–Response to Motion to Transfer Venue | Kenneth Bennight

  4. Pingback: Collin-County Whistle Blower Case Transferred from Dallas County to Collin County | Kenneth Bennight

  5. Pingback: Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Case: Plea to the Jurisdiction Granted | Kenneth Bennight

  6. Pingback: Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Case: Request for Formal Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law | Kenneth Bennight

  7. Pingback: Collin County Community College District: Due Date for Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law | Kenneth Bennight

  8. Pingback: Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit: Motion for New Trial Filed | Kenneth Bennight

  9. Pingback: Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit: Time for Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law | Kenneth Bennight

  10. Pingback: Report of Corruption in the Collin County Community College District | Kenneth Bennight

  11. Pingback: Collin County Community College District President Resigns | Kenneth Bennight

  12. Pingback: Hearing Date for Collin County Community College District’s Motion to Transfer Venue and Plea to the Jurisdiction | Kenneth Bennight

  13. Pingback: Collin County Community College District–Response to Motion to Transfer Venue | Kenneth Bennight

  14. Pingback: Collin-County Whistle Blower Case Transferred from Dallas County to Collin County | Kenneth Bennight

  15. Pingback: Notice of Past-Due Findings Filed in Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit | Kenneth Bennight

  16. Pingback: Judge Files Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in the Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit | Kenneth Bennight

  17. Pingback: Collin County Community College District: Management Attitude | Kenneth Bennight

  18. Pingback: Appeal Perfected in Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit | Kenneth Bennight

  19. Pingback: How Long Will the Appeal Take (Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit) | Kenneth Bennight

  20. Pingback: Appellate Court Docket Sheet for Whistleblower Suit Against Collin County Community College District | Kenneth Bennight

  21. Pingback: Clerk’s Record is Filed, Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Appeal | Kenneth Bennight

  22. Pingback: The Dallas Observer Picks Up on the College District Scandal | Kenneth Bennight

  23. Pingback: Chris Oldner Endorsed by San Antonio Express-News for Texas Court of Criminal Appeals | Kenneth Bennight

  24. Pingback: Whistleblower Brief Filed in Suit Against Collin County Community College District | Kenneth Bennight

  25. Pingback: Time Extended for Filing Collin County Community College District’s Brief | Kenneth Bennight

  26. Pingback: Sense of Irony Needed at Collin County Community College District? | Kenneth Bennight

  27. Pingback: Oral Argument in Collin County Community College District Case | Kenneth Bennight

  28. Pingback: Collin County Community College District Loses | Kenneth Bennight

  29. Pingback: News Reports on Collin County Community College Whistleblower Case | Kenneth Bennight

  30. Pingback: Connection Between Detective Novelette and Collin County Community College District Whistleblower Suit | Kenneth Bennight

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s